JESHUA BEN JUDAH

JESHUA BEN JUDAH
JESHUA BEN JUDAH (sometimes erroneously called Joshuaben Judah; his Arabic name was Abū al-Faraj Furqān ibn Asad; second half of the 11th century), Karaite scholar who lived in Jerusalem. A worthy pupil of his distinguished teacher Yūsuf al-Baṣīr (Joseph ha-Ro'eh), he was regarded by the Karaites as one of the outstanding savants of his century, although in later times his philosophical and exegetical works tended to be neglected. Jeshua's greatest contribution, however, was his decisive opposition to the so-called catenary theory (in Hebrew rikkuv, literally "compounding") of incest, which had the support of the majority of earlier Karaite jurists, from anan downward, which severely limited the circle of women whom a Karaite man could lawfully marry. Jeshua was not the first to oppose this theory – his teacher Yūsuf al-Baṣīr is said also to have been an opponent of it, as was an earlier authority, david b. boaz (second half of the tenth century). However, Jeshua's tract on the law of incest dealt with it incisively and in great detail, and since it was subsequently translated from its original Arabic into Hebrew (Sefer ha-Yashar (1908); extracts in Leon Nemoy's Karaite Anthology (1952), 127–32; cf. Steinschneider, Arab Lit, 91–94), it remained accessible to later Karaite scholars who knew no Arabic and thus retained its influence upon them. In order to loosen the ever tightening noose fastened by the catenary theory upon the physical survival of the Karaite group, Jeshua established the following principles: (1) The biblical dictum that man and wife become "one flesh" (Gen. 2:24) does not mean that all close relatives of the wife automatically become equally close to the husband, but merely refers to the couple's mutual affection and intimacy; (2) The biblical identification of the wife's "nakedness" with the husband's "nakedness" similarly has nothing to do with incest, but merely refers to the husband's duty to guard his wife's chastity, the violation of which is as much an injury to him as to her; (3) The biblical use of terms like "sister" or "aunt" with reference to distant or adopted relatives is merely figurative; (4) The forbidden degrees of relationship are those listed in Scripture, their blood relatives, and those derived from them by analogy used only once – piling analogy upon analogy (as was done by the adherents of the catenary theory) is both unlawful and absurd, since it has no definable limit. Jeshua's definition of incest became the rule in later codes of Karaite law, down to and including Elijah bashyazi 's authoritative code. Although Karaite limitations on permissible marriages remain more stringent than the Rabbanite ones, Jeshua is responsible for one of the very few radical reforms ever introduced in Karaite jurisprudence. Jeshua's other works comprise an Arabic translation of the Pentateuch with a longer and shorter philosophical commentary, and comments on Genesis and on the Decalogue, extant mostly in fragments. A short Hebrew tract on the law of incest (Iggeret ha-Teshuvah or Teshuvat ha-Ikkar, Eupatoria, 1834) was printed under his name, but his authorship of it seems uncertain. Two philosophical tracts are also ascribed to him. Like his teacher, Jeshua follows in the footsteps of the Muʿtazilite (see kalam ) school of Arab philosophers. He agrees with al-Baṣīr that certain knowledge of the creation of the world and the existence of God cannot be derived from the Bible alone but must come originally from rational speculation. Like al-Baṣīr he regards as the cornerstone of his religious philosophy the proof that the world was created in time. He also maintains that the Creator is not a "cause," i.e., an impersonal entity which by necessity produces other things from itself, but an "agent," i.e.,   one acting with will and choice. Jeshua offers several proofs for God's incorporeality. He likewise agrees with al-Baṣīr in regarding the nature of good and evil as absolute, not relative, and as binding upon God as well. God can do evil as well as good, but prefers to do good. Besides, all evildoing is the result of some need, but God has no needs, being self-sufficient; hence He does not do evil. God's purpose in creating the world cannot have been selfish, since God is without need, and must therefore have been the well-being of His creatures. Among Jeshua's pupils were the Byzantine scholars tobiah b. moses and jacob b. simeon , both translators of important Karaite works from the Arabic into Hebrew, and Ibn al-Tarās , a Karaite who engaged in vigorous missionary activity among Rabbanites in his native Spain. -BIBLIOGRAPHY: M. Schreiner, Studien ueber Jeschua ben Jehuda (1900); S. Poznański, The Karaite Literary Opponents of Saadiah Gaon (1908), 48–53, 103; Husik, Philosophy, 55–58; Guttmann, Philosophies, 78–81. (Leon Nemoy)

Encyclopedia Judaica. 1971.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Jeshua ben Judah — Jeshua ben Judah[1] was a Karaite scholar, exegete and philosopher, who lived in eleventh century Iraq (or Persia, according to some sources) or at Jerusalem. He was pupil of Joseph ben Abraham ha Ro eh. Jeshua was considered one of the highest… …   Wikipedia

  • Jeshua ben Judah — (fl. 11th cent.)    Palestinian Karaite scholar. He lived in Jeruslaem. His principal works are an Arabic translation of the Pentateuch with a philosophical commentary, a study of the law of incest, and philosophical tracts …   Dictionary of Jewish Biography

  • MEKHILTA OF R. SIMEON BEN YOḤAI — (Aram. דְּרַבִּי שִׁמְעוֹן בֶּן יוֹחַאי מְכִילְתָּא) (MS), a halakhic Midrash on Exodus from the school of R. akiva , which is attributed to R. Simeon b. Yohai because of his exposition at the beginning of the book. Several rishonim knew this… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • BEN SIRA, WISDOM OF — (also called Ecclesiasticus), a work of the Apocrypha, which, though usually known by this name, may have been called by its author, The Words of Simeon b. Jeshua, the title found on the Hebrew fragments. In Greek the book is called Σοφία (ʾIήσου …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • Joseph ben Abraham — (Heb. Yosef ben Avraham ha Kohen, also known as Yusuf al Basir [ [http://www.muslimphilosophy.com/ip/rep/J052.htm Karaism ] ] ) was a Karaite philosopher and theologian who flourished in Babylonia or Persia in the first half of the eleventh… …   Wikipedia

  • Jacob ben Reuben (Karaite) — Jacob ben Reuben (יעקב בן ראובן) was a Karaite scholar and Bible exegete of the eleventh century. He wrote a brief Hebrew language commentary on the entire Bible, which he entitled Sefer ha Osher, because, as he says in the introduction, the… …   Wikipedia

  • TOBIAS BEN MOSES HA-AVEL — (or ha Ma tik, the translator ; 11th century), karaite scholar. He laid the theoretical and educational foundations for establishing the Karaites in the Byzantine milieu. According to Elijah Bashyaẓi (Iggeret Gid ha Nasheh, 4a) Tobias studied… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • BAṢĪR, JOSEPH BEN ABRAHAM HA-KOHEN HARO'EH AL- — (Yūsuf al Basir; first half of 11th century), Karaite halakhist and philosopher, who originated from Iraq or Persia. Because he was blind he was euphemistically called al Basīr Abū Yūsuf Yaʿqūb ha Ro eh ( the Seeing ). Many Karaite authors… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • DAVID BEN BOAZ — (also called David ha Nasi or Abu Saʿīd David ben Boaz; 10th–11th centuries), Karaite scholar. According to Karaite tradition, David was a fifth generation removed from anan b. david b. boaz . It is reported that his   father died a martyr. One… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

  • ISRAEL (ben Samuel?) HA-DAYYAN HA-MA'ARAVI — (d. before 1354), Karaite scholar living in cairo . Israel, with his pupil japheth b. david ibn Ṣaghīr, is reported to have overcome the last vestiges of opposition to the reform of the Karaite law of incest, begun by jeshua b. judah and others… …   Encyclopedia of Judaism

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”